How to Choose a Legal Charter Operator in the Florida Keys

Published: March 7, 2020

Updated: October 29, 2026

Read Time: 4 minutes

/

Florida Keys Snapper

Choosing a charter should involve more than finding a boat, a few good pictures, and a price you like. You are trusting somebody with your family and your day on the ocean. Asking a few practical questions before booking is time well spent.

I built my business around being properly credentialed, permitted, and prepared for the activities I offer. Those details are part of the work behind your trip, even if they never appear in a dock picture. Here is what I would want to know before stepping aboard somebody else’s boat.

Ask About the Captain’s Credentials

For a captained passenger-for-hire trip, ask to see the captain’s valid U.S. Coast Guard Merchant Mariner Credential. It needs to be appropriate for the operation. A recreational boating safety card is a different document.

Ask how many passengers the boat is authorized to carry. For a typical small charter carrying more than six passengers for hire, ask about the required Coast Guard Certificate of Inspection. The details depend on the vessel and charter arrangement, so an operator should be able to explain how your trip is authorized.

You can also ask how the operator meets applicable drug and alcohol testing requirements. You do not need to become an expert in maritime paperwork, but you should receive straightforward answers about the basics.

The Coast Guard’s guidance on illegal charters explains what passengers should check before paying or boarding.

Check the Fishing Licenses and Permits

A captain’s credential and a fishing license serve different purposes. For a Florida saltwater fishing charter, ask about the FWC charter captain or charter boat license and whether it covers the people fishing on your trip.

Additional permits may be needed for particular species, federal waters, or protected areas. Lobstering and other harvesting activities can also involve specific licensing requirements. “We have a fishing license” is a starting point for the conversation, rather than the answer to every possible trip.

You can review FWC’s saltwater charter licensing information and NOAA’s Southeast fisheries permit resources for more detail.

Ask What the Insurance Covers

If your trip includes snorkeling, lobstering, or getting out at a sandbar, ask whether the operator’s insurance covers those specific activities. The word “insured” by itself does not explain the scope of a policy.

Coverage depends on the policy, its conditions, and its exclusions. I cannot tell you what another operator carries, and you should not have to guess. Ask for confirmation relevant to the trip you are booking. A waiver alone does not tell you what insurance coverage exists.

Look for Preparation and a Safety Briefing

A routine Coast Guard boarding helped prompt this article. During that particular stop, officers checked my identification, boat registration, and some safety equipment. They did not review every document connected with my charter business.

That experience reminded me that “the boat passed a check” does not answer every question a customer might have. Ask about life jackets suitable for your group, emergency procedures, and how weather affects the plan. Before departure, pay attention to the safety briefing and ask if anything is unclear.

Use Reviews Without Relying on Rankings Alone

Reviews and trip pictures can help you understand a business, but they cannot verify credentials, permits, or insurance. A polished advertisement is still an advertisement.

I would look for consistent information about who operates the trip, which boat you will use, what is included, and what happens when conditions change. Read reviews for patterns in communication and the experience aboard. Then ask your own questions.

A low price does not prove a charter is illegal, and a high price does not prove it is well run. Having a small online presence does not settle the question either. Documentation and clear answers tell you more than those shortcuts.

Know Who You Are Booking With

Before paying a deposit, confirm who is taking your reservation, who will captain the trip, and which boat is expected. Ask whether a booking service may assign your reservation to another operator.

Read the cancellation and weather policies, understand what your payment includes, and keep your confirmation. Use a payment process you trust. These are ordinary questions for a purchase that may be a significant part of your vacation budget.

I put time and money into maintaining the boat, equipment, and business behind my trips. That work is part of what you are paying for. I want you to understand the plan before we leave the dock so we can spend our time enjoying the water.

If you have questions about my boat, credentials, or a particular activity, ask me before you reserve your trip. I’m happy to explain what I offer and help you decide whether it fits your group.

Captain Kevin Johnsen holds up a mackerel

Captain Kevin Johnsen

Capt. Kevin Johnsen is a licensed USCG Master Captain and 40-year resident of Marathon, Florida. He runs Florida Keys Reel Adventures, offering hands-on fishing, spearfishing, snorkeling, and lobstering charters in the Middle Keys. When he's not on the water, he's probably thinking about being on the water.

Built for Adventure

Ready to Step Aboard?

Whether you're fishing, snorkeling, or diving for lobster, Captain Kevin has meticulously set this boat up to be the ideal platform for your adventure. From the upgraded seating to the pristine condition of the vessel, every detail reflects Kevin's commitment to quality and his guests' comfort.