September 2024 Florida Keys Fishing Report & Lobster Trip Tips

Published: September 14, 2024

Updated: October 29, 2026

Read Time: 4 minutes

/

Florida Keys Snapper

Fishing conditions and trip outlook as of September 14, 2024.

I spend a lot of time refining the trips I offer. I also need to keep refining how I explain them. My goal with these updates is to give you a useful picture of the conditions, the activities, and what to expect before you arrive.

Sometimes I get a little wordy. There is plenty happening out here, and I would rather talk through the important details before your trip than leave you guessing at the dock.

September Fishing: Early Starts Still Make Sense

We are halfway through September, and things are looking better than I expected. At the time of this report, the next ten days look encouraging weather-wise. It is still hot, but bait is starting to show up, and gulls and pelicans are returning. Fall feels a little closer, even if the thermometer has not quite received the message.

For this late-summer pattern, I am keeping half-day reef fishing trips in the morning. Early departures remain my preference for the other trips, too, and I expect that approach to continue into late October unless conditions change.

Yellowtail snapper fishing has been good on the deep reef, with mangrove snapper filling in on the shallower reefs. Offshore trips have had opportunities for mahi and blackfin tuna, though sharks have been a serious challenge around the tuna grounds.

Clear Reef Water, but Variable Lobster Visibility

The main reef has been fairly clear, with plenty of moon jellyfish around. Bring a long-sleeve rash guard for time in the water, and we will assess the conditions before choosing where to get in.

My deeper ocean-side lobster spots, roughly 12 to 18 feet deep, have been a different story. Visibility has often been poor enough to keep us from using them. A favorable tide has occasionally given us a workable window, but those openings have been inconsistent.

That has been frustrating after some productive shallow-reef lobster trips earlier in the season. It is also a reminder that a spot can hold lobster and still be unsuitable for the trip that day.

A Recent Lobster Trip That Came Together

One recent outing was a good example of teamwork. Three guests with a mix of experience visited 27 spots and finished with 16 keeper lobster during a four-hour trip.

They had challenges and needed time to learn, just like other groups. They were comfortable snorkeling, listened to the approach, and improved as the trip progressed. Conditions were a little better than on some previous outings, and we made good use of the opportunities available.

That was one trip’s result, rather than a catch target for every group. Other trips this season have visited around five to ten spots and finished with three to six keeper lobster. Conditions and the range of locations suitable for each group have varied considerably.

Is a Lobster Trip Right for Your Group?

Lobstering is an active, demanding activity, even on a good day. This September, warm water, inconsistent visibility, and current have added to the challenge.

I choose locations by balancing the conditions with what your group can comfortably do. Staying shallower or choosing clearer water and less current may be the right decision, but it can also narrow the places we can search.

Read the published participation requirements before booking, and speak with me about everyone’s snorkeling and freediving experience. Being comfortable swimming at the surface is different from being able to dive down and work near the bottom.

The point of that conversation is to choose an appropriate activity. A charter should not depend on anyone pushing beyond their abilities to keep up with the plan or catch more lobster.

Learning about the equipment and trip process beforehand can help you understand what is involved. Reading or watching videos does not replace the in-water skills the activity requires. If you are unsure whether your group meets the requirements, ask before reserving.

As of this update, the wind forecast looks encouraging, and recreational boat traffic has eased since August. Those are positives. Visibility remains something we will need to evaluate for each trip.

Fall Maintenance and Booking Ahead

I am also arranging some multi-day maintenance on the boat during this quieter stretch. That work depends partly on when the people helping with it are available, so an open date on the calendar may become a maintenance day.

If you have particular dates in mind, get in touch early so we can confirm availability. Last-minute bookings may still be possible, but advance planning helps me organize the work around scheduled trips.

I want these updates to help you make a confident choice. Some activities fit your group better than others, and explaining the requirements is part of my job. Tell me about your interests, experience, and concerns so we can put together a realistic plan.

Curious about lobstering but unsure whether it suits everyone coming along? Send me your questions and a little about your group’s experience. I will talk you through the requirements and seasonal options so you can choose a day on the water that makes sense for your crew.

Captain Kevin Johnsen holds up a mackerel

Captain Kevin Johnsen

Capt. Kevin Johnsen is a licensed USCG Master Captain and 40-year resident of Marathon, Florida. He runs Florida Keys Reel Adventures, offering hands-on fishing, spearfishing, snorkeling, and lobstering charters in the Middle Keys. When he's not on the water, he's probably thinking about being on the water.

Built for Adventure

Ready to Step Aboard?

Whether you're fishing, snorkeling, or diving for lobster, Captain Kevin has meticulously set this boat up to be the ideal platform for your adventure. From the upgraded seating to the pristine condition of the vessel, every detail reflects Kevin's commitment to quality and his guests' comfort.