Conditions and trip outlook as of October 16, 2024.
Well, October has certainly been interesting. Getting a fishing report together has been difficult between storm preparations, cleanup, and trying to get back on the water.
We are grateful to have avoided the direct hits that affected Florida’s west coast. My heart goes out to everyone dealing with the damage. Even without a direct hit here, the weeks of moving seagrass and sand, cutting branches, hauling boats, and repairing docks have added up. Some days it has felt like we finish one round just in time to prepare for the next.
I got the boat back in the water a few days ago after several rounds on and off the trailer. The temperature change was noticeable: we were around 86°F before the storms, and I measured about 81°F coming around the island today. Summer seems to have handed things over to fall in a hurry.

Cooling Water and Bait Point Toward Better Reef Fishing
There are encouraging signs for fishing. When I cannot spend much time on the water, I still pay attention to what is moving around us. Migrating birds, the fall mullet run, and large schools of pilchards arriving near the dock all get my attention. More bait gives predators a reason to show up.
The reef looks like a sensible place to start as conditions improve. My late-September snapper catches were mostly smaller fish, which fits the hot-water pattern we had been seeing.
From what I am observing, the cooling trend is several weeks ahead of last year’s. I am hoping that brings better-sized yellowtail snapper onto the reef and more opportunities for mutton snapper around the wrecks. That is an outlook to work with, rather than a catch report from trips I have not yet run.
Offshore Tuna, Mahi, and Shark Challenges
This time of year usually brings fewer mahi and more focus on tuna. The tuna bite has been good, but aggressive sharks have made getting hooked fish to the boat a challenge.
Storm-related floating debris may also give us places to look for mahi in the Gulf Stream. Finding a productive floater can help concentrate fish that would otherwise be scattered. I did not find one on my last trip, so that remains something to look for when we get another suitable offshore opportunity.
Snorkeling Is on Hold, and My Lobster Trips Have Ended
For this October period, I am putting in-water activities on hold. Poor visibility and the change in conditions have limited snorkeling enough that I am not planning on it for most of the remaining month.
I am also ending my lobster trips for the year. The statewide lobster season was still open at the time of this update, but that does not mean the local conditions suit the trips I offer. Cooler water, poor visibility, and limited lobster opportunities are not the combination I want to take you out for.
I know that is disappointing if lobstering was on your vacation list. I would rather explain the limits before you book and discuss whether a fishing trip would give your group a better day.
A Realistic Plan for a Disrupted October
These disruptions have made for a difficult stretch of business, and I would love to be running more trips. I also know many of you have traveled a long way and have been looking forward to getting on the ocean. That deserves an honest conversation about what is possible.
More wind is in the near-term outlook. Depending on the direction and strength, protected areas may let us put together a shorter-range fishing plan focused on comfort and fun. Some days will still be unsuitable, and we need to leave room for that decision.
I am hoping November brings a calmer, drier stretch and more options. For now, flexibility matters. A good day does not always need a trophy fish or a full freezer. Learning something, catching a few fish, and enjoying time together can be plenty worthwhile when we choose a trip that fits the conditions.

If weather has you wondering what to do with your day on the water, ask me what is practical for your dates. I will give you a straight answer about the conditions and help you decide whether an adjusted trip makes sense for your group.